Tribunals · By council
Tribunal decisions in Rotherham
Every business rates appeal for a property in Rotherham decided by the Valuation Tribunal for England since 2020 — what was argued, what the Valuation Officer conceded, and what the tribunal decided.
Valuation Tribunal for England Every judgment in full
Decisions since 2020
24
from 26 appeals; the rest have no written decision
Won a reduction
83% of 24
where the ratepayer attended or made submissions
Conceded before the hearing
22%
2 cases where the Valuation Officer cut the value first, median 23%
Rateable value removed
£254,000
by tribunal decisions in 6 cases, median cut 20%
Which arguments succeed
Ground argued · cases · share that won any reduction. Attended cases only; a case can argue several grounds.
| Ground | Cases | Won |
|---|---|---|
| Valuation method | 19 | 95% |
| Comparable assessments (tone) | 8 | 88% |
| Rental evidence | 5 | 60% |
The decisions
Showing 25 of 25 decisions · 21 won a reduction
| List | Sought | VO conceded | Decisive ground | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Boundary Mills, Unit 2, S60 5TRRetail Warehouse and Premises | 2023 | 17 Dec 2025 | £1,050,000 | £565,500 | — | £910,000 | — | Allowed in part |
| Candlelight Products, Ustun House, S65 3SHWarehouse and premises | 2017 | 26 Aug 2025 | £327,500 | £285,000 | — | £285,000 | — | Allowed |
| N Y Commodities, Harrison Street, S61 1EEWorkshop and premises | 2017 | 11 Aug 2025 | £71,500 | £47,750 | £54,500 | £54,500 | Quantum or end allowance | Dismissed |
| N Y Commodities, Harrison Street, S61 1EEWorkshop and premises | 2017 | 11 Aug 2025 | £79,500 | £52,750 | £61,500 | £61,500 | — | Dismissed |
| ADVERTISING SITE 0403 0102 OPP 65 ROTHERHAM ROAD, MALTBY, S66 8LZAdvertising site - bus shelter digital display | 2017 | 14 Nov 2024 | — | — | — | £2,550 | Valuation method | Allowed in part |
| ADVERTISING SITE 0403 0325 BUS SHELTER OPP 27 HIGH STREET, Maltby, S66 8LGAdvertising rights and premises - digital display bus shelter roadside | 2017 | 14 Nov 2024 | — | — | — | £2,550 | Valuation method | Allowed in part |
| ADVERTISING SITE 0403 0195 O/S 350, BAWTRY ROAD, HELLABY, S66 8EYAdvertising site - bus shelter digital display | 2017 | 14 Nov 2024 | — | — | — | £2,550 | Valuation method | Allowed in part |
| ADVERTISING SITE 0403 0148 AT 92 HIGH STREET, Maltby, Maltby, S66 7BNAdvertising rights and premises - digital display bus shelter | 2017 | 14 Nov 2024 | — | £1,035 | — | £2,550 | Valuation method | Allowed in part |
| ADVERTISING SITE 0403 0344 E/O DALTON LANE OPP, MILHOUSE COURT, DONCASTER ROAD, S65 3ETAdvertising rights and premises; digital displays at bus shelters | 2017 | 14 Nov 2024 | — | — | — | £2,550 | Valuation method | Allowed in part |
| ADVERTISING SITE 0403 0337 AT, FAIRFIELD PARK, MANVERS WAY, WATH UPON DEARNE, WATH UPON DEARNE, S62 5AAAdvertising rights and premises (digital display, six-sheet bus shelter) | 2017 | 14 Nov 2024 | — | — | — | £2,550 | Valuation method | Allowed in part |
| ADVERTISING SITE 0403 0025, FENTON ROAD, S61 3RGAdvertising rights and premises; digital display at bus shelters | 2017 | 14 Nov 2024 | — | — | — | £2,550 | Valuation method | Allowed in part |
| ADVERTISING SITE 0403 0114 OPP KEPPEL ROAD, UPPER WORTLEY ROAD, THORPE HESLEY, THORPE HESLEY, S61 2SZAdvertising rights and premises; digital display; bus shelters | 2017 | 14 Nov 2024 | — | — | — | £2,550 | Valuation method | Allowed in part |
| ADVERTISING SITE 0403 0345 OPP SOUTH STREET, MEADOW BANK ROAD, S61 2NFAdvertising rights and premises - digital display bus shelters | 2017 | 14 Nov 2024 | — | — | — | £2,550 | Valuation method | Allowed in part |
| ADVERTISING SITE 0403 0204 MEADOWBANK ROAD OPP, PEMBROKE STREET, S61 2NFAdvertising site - digital display at bus shelter | 2017 | 14 Nov 2024 | — | — | — | £1,110 | — | Allowed in part |
| ADVERTISING SITE 0403 0151 AT UPPER WORTLEY ROAD & OAKS LANE, S61 2AAAdvertising rights and premises, digital display at bus shelters | 2017 | 14 Nov 2024 | — | — | — | £2,550 | Valuation method | Allowed in part |
| ADVERTISING SITE 0403 0152 OPP BRADGATE LANE, WORTLEY ROAD, S61 1LHAdvertising rights and premises; digital display at bus shelters | 2017 | 14 Nov 2024 | — | — | — | £2,550 | Valuation method | Allowed in part |
| ADVERTISING SITE 0403 0104 O/S JUBILEE COTTAGES, BAWTRY ROAD, S60 5NXAdvertising rights and premises; digital displays at bus shelters | 2017 | 14 Nov 2024 | — | — | — | £2,550 | — | Allowed in part |
| ADVERTISING SITE 0403 0175 ON BUS SHELTER OPP, 148 BROOM ROAD, S60 2SRAdvertising rights and premises - digital displays at bus shelters | 2017 | 14 Nov 2024 | — | — | — | £2,550 | Valuation method | Allowed in part |
| ADVERTISING SITE 0403 0339 SOUTH OF STADIUM WAY, ROTHERHAM ROAD, PARKGATE, PARKGATE, S60 1TGAdvertising rights and premises; digital display bus shelters | 2017 | 14 Nov 2024 | £2,550 | £425 | — | £2,550 | — | Allowed in part |
| ADVERTISING SITE 0403 0048 JUNCTION OF NORTH DRIVE &, GREASBROUGH ROAD, S60 1QFAdvertising rights and premises - digital displays at bus shelters | 2017 | 14 Nov 2024 | — | — | — | £2,550 | Valuation method | Allowed in part |
| ADVERTISING SITE 0403 0327 ON BUS SHELTER NEAR, 77 SHEFFIELD ROAD, S60 1DAAdvertising rights and premises; digital displays at bus shelters | 2017 | 14 Nov 2024 | — | — | — | £2,550 | Valuation method | Allowed in part |
| Church House, Church Street, S63 7RDPublic house and premises | 2017 | 21 May 2024 | £54,500 | £31,000 | — | £31,000 | Valuation method | Allowed |
| Costa Coffee Drive Thru, 23 Retail World, S60 1TGRestaurant and premises | 2017 | 19 Feb 2024 | £74,500 | £57,000 | — | £61,500 | — | Allowed in part |
| Unit 22, Stadium Way, Parkgate Retail World, Parkgate Retail World, S60 1TGSingle storey modern restaurant | 2017 | 12 Feb 2024 | £139,000 | £119,000 | — | £139,000 | Valuation method | Dismissed |
| INTOCAST UK LTD, CHESTERTON ROAD, EASTWOOD TRADING ESTATE, s65 1stWorkshop and premises | 2017 | 22 Mar 2021 | £47,000 | £36,000 | — | £47,000 | — | Dismissed |
Values are as stated in each decision; a dash means the document does not state that figure. Where a decision covers several properties, the first-listed is shown. Cash-machine appeals are listed but excluded from the statistics above. Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0 — decisions © Valuation Tribunal Service.